The correct answer is $\boxed{\text{C. }C_1 = C_2}$.
The capacitance of a parallel-plate capacitor is given by the equation
$$C = \frac{\varepsilon_0 A}{d}$$
where $\varepsilon_0$ is the permittivity of free space, $A$ is the area of the plates, and $d$ is the distance between the plates. The resistivity of the material of the plates does not affect the capacitance.
In this case, the two capacitors have the same area and the same distance between the plates, so they have the same capacitance.