The correct answer is: A. All, but she.
The sentence "All, but her, had made an attempt" is grammatically correct. The word "her" is the object of the preposition "but," and it is in the objective case. The word "herself" is the reflexive pronoun, and it is used when the subject and object of the sentence are the same person. In this sentence, the subject is "all" and the object is "her," so "herself" is not the correct word to use.
The word "she" is the subject pronoun, and it is used when the subject of the sentence is a female person. In this sentence, the subject is "all," which is not a female person, so "she" is not the correct word to use.
The word "her" is the object pronoun, and it is used when the object of the sentence is a female person. In this sentence, the object is "her," so "her" is the correct word to use.
The sentence "All, but her, had made an attempt" means that everyone except her had made an attempt.