Statement 'a' is false: While the UK does not have constitutional review of primary legislation in the sense of striking it down based on a codified constitution (due to parliamentary sovereignty), judicial review is permitted for administrative actions and to check the compatibility of legislation with the Human Rights Act 1998 or EU law (when applicable). The statement "no judicial review of legislation is permitted" is an oversimplification and technically false. Statement 'b' is false: The judiciary in the United States, while exercising strong judicial review, does recognize limits on its scope (e.g., limitations based on standing, ripeness, political questions, etc.). The claim that it "recognises no limit on the scope of judicial review" is incorrect.
Consider the following statements : a. In Britain, no judicial review of legislation is permitted. b. Judiciary in India is not as supreme as in the United States of America which recognises no limit on the scope of judicial review.
Asked in MPSC CS Prelims 2015 · Topic: The Governance System (Role of Judiciary in Governance)
More Indian Polity and Governance questions
- The salary and allowances of the public prosecutors are given by
- Which one of the following statement is not correct about public interest litigation?
- The Essence of "Judicial Activism" is an
- Who said, Delegated legislation and administrative tribunals are the manifestation of "New despotism"?
- - In this book, he strongly criticized the increasing practice of Parliament delegating law- making powers to the executive (delegated legislation) and the growing role of administrative tribunals in deciding disputes, arguing that it was undermining the rule of law and leading to executive tyranny. 865. Which of the following is not correct in relation to admission?
- What is 'fact in issue'?
- Evidence to conspiracy under Section 10 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 is applicable to
- Which one of the following is related with the doctrine of 'Separation of Powers' ?