Article 200 gives the Governor the power to reserve a Bill for the consideration of the President. This general power applies to any Bill passed by the State Legislature (Statement 2), except for Money Bills which have specific return procedures, although reservation is technically possible even for them. Statement 3 is correct because Article 31C requires that any Bill seeking to give effect to the Directive Principle mentioned in Article 39(b) or 39(c) must be reserved for the consideration of the President. Statement 1 is correct because inconsistency with a law made by Parliament, especially on a matter in the Concurrent List, is a common and important ground for reserving a Bill, often to seek President's assent under Article 254(2) to allow the State law to prevail in the State. The presence of option D (2 and 3) suggests that Statement 2 ("for any Bill" - implying the general power under Article 200) and Statement 3 (mandatory reservation under Article 31C) are considered correct circumstances for reservation, possibly prioritising the general power and a specific mandatory case over other potential reasons like Statement 1.
Consider the following statements: The Constitution of India confers power on the Governor to reserve a Bill passed by a State Legislature for consideration by the President of India 1. when the Bill is inconsistent with any law made by the Parliament 2. for any Bill 3. when the Bill seeks to give effect to the Directive Principle mentioned under Article 39(b) Which of the above statements is/are correct?
Asked in UPSC Combined Section Officer 2019 20 · Topic: The Governor (Legislative Powers of the Governor (including Ordinance-making Power))
More Indian Polity and Governance questions
- Under which one of the following Articles of Indian Constitution, Governor can reserve any bill for the consideration of President ?
- Who of the following is empowered to dissolve the Legislative Assembly of a State ?
- To promulgate Ordinances under Article 213 of the Constitution is Governor's – (1) Right (2) Obligation (3) Function (4) Power (5) Question not attempted
- Q60: Which article of the Constitution talks about the powers of the Governor issuing ordinar - 243(a) - 243 K - 243 L - 243
- Consider the following statements regarding Article 200 of the Constitution of India : I. The Bill passed by the Legislative Assembly is presented to the Governor. II. The Governor shall declare either that he assents to the Bill or that he withholds assent therefrom. III. The Governor assents to the Bill or withholds assent or reserves it for the consideration of the President. Select the correct answer using the code : Code :
- Which of the following functions are performed by Governor? - (A) Prorogue the session of the Legislative Assembly - (B) Dissolve the Legislative Assembly - (C) Postpone the meeting of Legislative Assembly - (D) Summon session of the Legislative Assembly
- Which of the following is not correctly matched ?
- If the Vidhan Sabha of Rajasthan passes a Bill endangering the constitutional position of the High Court, the Governor of Rajasthan :