- British officials and historians had varied interpretations of the revolt, often emphasizing religious fanaticism, sepoy grievances, or conspiracies. - Indian historians also hold diverse views, ranging from calling it the "First War of Independence" (like V.D. Savarkar) to more critical assessments questioning its unity, national character, and goals (like R.C. Majumdar). - These quotes represent specific historical interpretations.
Given below are two statements: Statement I : "The 1857 Revolt was a war of fanatic religionists against Christians” — Statement by Sir James Outram. Statement II : "The so called First National War of Independence of 1857- is neither first, nor National, nor a war of Independence.” — Statement by R.C. Majumdar. In the light of the above statements, choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below:
Asked in HPPSC HPAS Prelims 2023 · Topic: Revolt of 1857 (Nature and Character of the Revolt (Views of different historians: Sepoy Mutiny vs. First War of Independence))
Show answer
Answer: A. Both Statement I and Statement II are correct
More Modern History of India questions
- Consider the following statements: (1) In 1910, at Allahabad Session of Indian National Congress was “Jana-Gana- Mana” sung for the first time. (2) Swami Dayanand Saraswati had hoisted the ‘Pakhand Khandini Pataka’ at Allahabad in 1867 A.D. (3) The last Act was the Charter Act of 1853 for the East India Company. (4) The modern educated Indians also did not support the Revolt of 1857. Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
- Which of the following aspects of the revolt of 1857 is not correct ?
- Who called the "1857 Uprising" "A War of Independence"?
- The following leading British Parliamentarian and Politician admitted that the Revolt of 1857 was a National Revolt and not a Military Mutiny :
- The Azamgarh Proclamation of August 25, 1857 stressed on which one of the following issues ?
- Which one of the following statements about the Revolt of 1857 is correct ?
- Which one of the following statements about the ishtahars issued during the Revolt of 1857 is correct?
- The statement "The so-called first national war of independence was neither first, nor national, nor a war of independence" is associated with