The Comptroller and Auditor-General of India (CAG) is appointed by the President and can only be removed from office in the manner and on the grounds specified in Article 124(4) of the Constitution, which is the same procedure as for the removal of a Judge of the Supreme Court. This procedure involves a resolution passed by both Houses of Parliament based on proved misbehaviour or incapacity. Therefore, Parliament does play a role in the removal of the CAG.Let's re-examine the options assuming the question implies direct parliamentary intervention without requiring a judicial-like impeachment process.The Chairman of UPSC, Judges of the High Court, and Judges of the Supreme Court are all removed through an impeachment process which requires a resolution passed by both Houses of Parliament.The CAG's removal is also through an address from both Houses of Parliament.However, if the question is subtly asking for an official whose removal is solely by the President's order without parliamentary involvement, then none of these options perfectly fit as all have a parliamentary role in their removal.Let's consider the common understanding and UPSC practices. The removal of Judges of Supreme Court and High Court, and the Chairman of UPSC, all require impeachment by Parliament. The CAG's removal is also on similar grounds and via a parliamentary address.There seems to be a potential ambiguity in the question or options if the intent is to find someone whose removal has no parliamentary role.Let's assume there might be a misunderstanding in the premise of the question or options provided for ID 98735.If we strictly interpret "Parliament play no role," then for all these posts, Parliament plays a significant role in their removal (impeachment or address by both houses).Let's reconsider the typical UPSC style. Often, such questions might have a slight nuance. For instance, the President can remove certain appointed officials without parliamentary consent, but that's not listed here.Given the options, and the standard constitutional procedures - Chairman of UPSC: Removed by President on grounds of misbehaviour or incapacity, after inquiry, and subject to removal by Parliament. - Judges of High Court/Supreme Court: Removed by President on grounds of misbehaviour or incapacity, after impeachment by Parliament. - CAG: Removed by President on grounds of misbehaviour or incapacity, after address from both Houses of Parliament.It is possible the question implies direct dismissal by the President without the complex impeachment process. In that case, none of these perfectly fit.However, let's search for potential interpretations or errors. If we assume there's a subtle distinction in the process, then we need to be very precise.Let's re-evaluate based on typical UPSC question construction. It's possible one of these has a different primary mode of removal.Upon further reflection and checking constitutional provisions, all the listed officials require a parliamentary address or impeachment for removal on grounds of misbehaviour or incapacity. This suggests there might be an error in the question or the provided options, as the premise that Parliament plays "no role" is incorrect for any of them.However, if we are forced to choose the "least" direct parliamentary involvement, or if there's an alternative removal mechanism not tied to misbehaviour/ incapacity that's more direct for one, we'd need to know that.Let's assume the question is flawed or there's a very specific interpretation intended.Correction based on common knowledge and typical UPSC exam patterns In many such questions, the intent is to differentiate between an impeachment process and other forms of removal. However, for UPSC Chairman, Judges of SC/HC, and CAG, the removal is generally through an impeachment-like process involving parliamentary resolutions.Let's search for external information regarding this specific question if it's a known PYQ.Without further context or clarification, this question is problematic. However, if we must select an answer, let's consider if any are removable by the President on grounds other than misbehaviour/incapacity and without parliamentary involvement. None are.Let's revisit the possibility of a misinterpretation.Could the question be interpreted as "in whose removal does the Parliament not initiate the process directly"? Still problematic.Let's consider a possibility that the question is framed around the initial step. For example, the President can initiate proceedings against a judge or CAG based on specific grounds, but the removal itself requires parliamentary sanction.However, there is a known factual error in the provided options if the question is as stated and expected to have a correct answer among these.Let me provide the correct information about removal for each: Chairman of the UPSC Removed by the President on grounds of misbehaviour or incapacity, after an inquiry, and subject to removal by Parliament as per Article 317. Judges of the High Court Removed by the President on grounds of misbehaviour or incapacity, through impeachment by Parliament (Article 217). Judges of the Supreme Court Removed by the President on grounds of misbehaviour or incapacity, through impeachment by Parliament (Article 124(4)). Comptroller and Auditor-General of India Removed by the President on grounds of misbehaviour or incapacity, by an order of the President passed after an address by each House of Parliament supported by a majority of the total membership of that House and by a majority of not less than two-thirds of the members of that House present and voting (Article 148(1)).As evident, Parliament plays a role in the removal of all these officials. Therefore, the premise of the question, "In the removal of which of the following officials does the Parliament play no role?" is fundamentally flawed given these options.If forced to pick a "least role" or if there's a very specific, often-tested distinction, it's impossible to determine without further context or clarification of the question's intent.Given this significant issue, I cannot confidently provide a "Correct Option" and a meaningful explanation for ID 98735 as presented. The question as posed has no correct answer among the given choices based on constitutional law.Let's proceed assuming there might be a widely circulated erroneous answer for this question in some study materials that the UPSC might test against, or a very obscure interpretation. However, adhering to accuracy, the question is unanswerable as is.For the purpose of demonstration, if we were to assume a poorly phrased question aiming to ask about someone removable by President's order without the full impeachment procedure, one might incorrectly lean towards the CAG or UPSC Chairman as they have "inquiry" clauses. But even these require a parliamentary address.I will skip providing a definitive answer for 98735 as it is factually incorrect as stated.
In the removal of which of the following officials does the Parliament play no role?
Asked in Extension officer (EO) 2019 · Topic: The Attorney General and the C.A.G. (Removal of CAG: Procedure and Grounds (like Supreme Court Judge))
Show answer
Answer: D. Comptroller and Auditor-General of India
More Indian Polity and Governance questions
- Which Officer of the Government of India has the right to take part in the proceedings of Parliament of India even though he is not a member?
- Which of the following are correct? 1. Advocate General is a constitutional institution formed under Article 165. 2. Attorney General is not a full-time counsel for the government and he is not debarred from private legal practice. 3. Attorney General enjoys all the privileges and immunities that are available to the Member of Parliament.
- In the performance of his official duties, the Attorney General shall have a right of audience in
- Consider the following statements about the Attorney General of India: He is appointed by the President of India. He must have the same qualifications as are required for a judge of the High Court. He has the right to speak in either House of Parliament. He can be removed by following the process of impeachment. He has the right of audience in all courts in the territory of India. Which of the above mentioned statements are correct ?
- Assertion [A] : Attorney - General of India has the privilege of addressing both the houses of Parliament. Reason [R] : Attorney - General enjoys the same previleges and immunities as the members of Parliament.
- Who among the following has the right to participate in the parliamentary proceedings ?
- Which of the following statements are correct ? The attorney general of India must have the qualifications as that re‐ 1. quired by a judge of the supreme court. enjoys the same privileges and immunities 2. as the members of Parliament. has the right of audience in all courts of 3. India. his salaries and expenses are charged on 4. the Consolidated Fund of India. Select the correct answer using the code given below :
- Which one of the following statements about the Attorney-General of India is NOT correct ?