The correct answer is D. no article.

The word "same" means "identical" or "indistinguishable." In this sentence, it is used to compare the time that Mary and I arrived. Since the time is identical, there is no need for an article.

A, B, and C are incorrect because they are all articles. Articles are used to introduce nouns, and in this sentence, the noun is "time." However, the time is not being introduced, it is being compared. Therefore, no article is needed.