The correct answer is: A. have estimated

The sentence is in the present perfect tense, which is used to talk about things that have happened or been true up to the present moment. In this case, the speaker is saying that they have estimated the value of the picture, and that their estimate is that it is worth at least $500.

The other options are not correct because they do not use the present perfect tense. Option B, "is," is in the present tense, which would be used to talk about things that are true right now. Option C, "estimated," is in the simple past tense, which would be used to talk about things that happened at a specific time in the past. Option D, "was," is also in the simple past tense, but it would only be used if the speaker was talking about a picture that no longer exists. Option E, "have estimated," is also in the present perfect tense, but it would only be used if the speaker was talking about multiple pictures that they had estimated the value of.

In conclusion, the correct answer is: A. have estimated