It is binding on the Supreme Court to give its opinion on any matter referred to it by the President. At least Five Judge Bench of the Supreme Court hears any reference made to it under its power of Advisory Jurisdiction. The opinion given by the Supreme Court on a reference under Advisory Jurisdiction is not binding on the President. - Statement 1 is incorrect: Under Article 143(1), the President may refer a question of law or fact of public importance to the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court may give its opinion. Giving an opinion is discretionary for the Court in such cases (though it has generally provided opinions when asked). However, under Article 143(2) (disputes arising out of pre-constitution treaties/agreements), the Supreme Court shall give its opinion. Statement 1 is too broad stating it is "binding on the Supreme Court to give its opinion on any matter referred". - Statement 2 is correct: References under Article 143, like constitutional matters under Article 145(3), must be heard by a bench of at least five judges of the Supreme Court. - Statement 3 is correct: The opinion given by the Supreme Court under its advisory jurisdiction is advisory, not binding on the President. The President is free to accept or reject the opinion. The opinion is also not considered a judicial pronouncement and is not binding precedent on courts in future cases.
Which of the following statements are correct regarding Advisory Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court?
Asked in GPSC Prelims CSP 1 2021 · Topic: The Supreme Court (Advisory Jurisdiction)
More Indian Polity and Governance questions
- Consider the following legal matters included in the advisory opinions rendered by the Supreme Court of India under Article 143(1) of the Constitution: Match List - I with List - II: List - I List - II
- Consider the legal issues involved in followings advisory opinion rendered by the Supreme Court of India under Article 143(1) of the Constitution. Match List - I with List - II : List - I List - II Legislative Priv‐
- Which one of the following does not fall under the jurisdiction of the apex court of India?
- The Supreme Court of India is different from its counterpart in the U. S. A. :
- The Supreme Court of India tenders advice to the President on a matter of law or fact
- The Supreme Court of India exercises advisory jurisdiction under which Article of the Constitution of India?
- Which one of the following Articles of the Constitution of India allows the President to seek advice from the Supreme Court on any matter of public importance ?
- Who has the right under the Constitution to seek the opinion of the Supreme Court on question of law ?