- Federalism implies a division of powers between the central government and regional governments. The Indian Constitution is federal in structure but with a strong unitary bias. Features that concentrate power at the Centre or reduce the autonomy of states are often seen as violating or diluting federal principles. - A. Office of the Governor: The Governor is appointed by the President (Union executive) and acts as the head of the state executive. The Governor can reserve state bills for the President's consideration and can recommend the imposition of President's Rule in the state, significantly impacting state autonomy. This is a key unitary feature. - B. Central Services (All India Services): Services like IAS and IPS are recruited and trained by the Centre but serve in states. They occupy top administrative positions in the states, and while under the administrative control of the state government, disciplinary action often requires Union government approval. This arrangement can potentially dilute state control over its administration and is considered a unitary feature. - C. Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG): The CAG is appointed by the President and audits the accounts of both the Union and State governments. While the CAG's role is essential for financial accountability, the unitary appointment process (by the Centre) and the fact that the CAG audits state accounts is sometimes seen as a feature that runs counter to the idea of completely independent financial structures at the state level in a strictly federal system. - D. Emergency Powers: Articles 352, 356, and 360 grant the Union government extraordinary powers during emergencies, allowing it to take over the legislative and executive functions of the states (Article 356), or centralize financial control (Article 360). This suspension of normal federal relations is a clear departure from federal principles during such periods. - All four listed items are commonly discussed in the context of the unitary features or centralising tendencies of the Indian Constitution, which dilute its strictly federal character. Therefore, all four can be seen as potentially violating or at least running counter to pure federal principles.
Which of the following violate the federal principles of the Indian Constitution ? A. Office of the Governor B. Central Services. C. Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General D. Emergency Powers
Asked in APPSC Group II Mains paper 1 2025 · Topic: The Governance System (Role of Executive in Governance)
More Indian Polity and Governance questions
- All revenues received by the Union Government by way of taxes and other receipts for the conduct of Government business are credited to
- In a Parliamentary system the executive is responsible:
- Who is the Chief Minister of Maharashtra?
- The first women Chief Minister of South India
- Who is the highest law officer in the States of India under Article 165?
- Which one among the following features of the Constitution of India is indicative of the fact that the real executive power is vested in the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister in India?
- Choose the most appropriate alternative : Parliamentary Government is also known as
- Who is called the 'Father of Election Science'?