- First Judges Case (1982): CJI's opinion is consultative, executive has final say. - Second Judges Case (1993): Established collegium system, CJI's opinion (with collegium) has primacy. - Third Judges Case (1998): Clarified the size and consultation process of the collegium, reinforced judicial primacy.
Which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct? 1. The judgment in First Judges Case declared that the Primacy of The CJI's recommendations to the President can be refused for cogent reasons. 2. The judgment in Second Judges Case declared that "justiciability" and "primacy" required that the CJI be given the "primal" role in such appointments. 3. The judgment in Three Judges Case ruled out the concept of "primacy" of the highest judiciary over the executive.
Asked in GPSC Prelims CSP 1 2018 · Topic: The Supreme Court (Landmark Judgments and Doctrines)
More Indian Polity and Governance questions
- The Supreme Court's I. R. Coelho Judgment (2007) is related to:
- I R Coelho judgment (2007) of the Supreme Court deals with :
- Consider the following statements regarding FASTER:
- The Doctrine of Fundamental Rights cannot be amended under Article 368 was propounded by the Supreme Court of India in
- Consider the following statements: Pravara v. Union of India Dwaraka Das v. Union of India Kesavananda Bharathi Ors v. Union of India N. Arunchalam (Dead) Anr. v. Union of India
- Which judgement of the Supreme Court declared transgenders as the 'third community' and ordered job applications to have a separate column for the third gender?
- In which of the following cases, the Supreme Court recognised sex work as a profession? (1) Laxmibai Chandaragi vs. State of Karnataka (2) Devilal vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (3) Satbir Singh vs. State of Haryana (4) Budhadev Karmakar vs. State of West Bengal Choose the correct answer form the options given below :
- The ‘Basic Structure Doctrine’ was enunciated by the Supreme Court during the: