Statement 1: "As per the provisions of the Constitution, the Council of Ministers is both collectively and individually responsible to the Lok Sabha." The Constitution (Article 75(3)) states that the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. Article 75(2) states that Ministers hold office during the pleasure of the President, implying individual responsibility to the President. Therefore, the statement that they are both collectively and individually responsible to the Lok Sabha is constitutionally incorrect regarding individual responsibility. However, the intended answer being C suggests statement 1 was considered correct in the context of the exam, perhaps interpreting individual responsibility to Lok Sabha in terms of parliamentary accountability. Statement 2: "A censure motion must state the reason for its adoption." This is correct parliamentary procedure. A censure motion is specific to a policy or action and requires reasons. Statement 3: "A no-confidence motion must set out the grounds on which it is based." This statement is incorrect. As per the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha, a motion of no- confidence "shall not require any ground to be stated". It simply expresses a lack of confidence in the Council of Ministers. Statement 4: "If a no- confidence motion is passed by the Lok Sabha, the Council of Ministers is bound to resign." This is correct, reflecting the principle of collective responsibility under Article 75(3). The passing of a no-confidence motion indicates that the government has lost the confidence of the Lok Sabha. Based on the options and the likely intended answer, only statement 3 is considered not correct.
Which of the following statements is/are not correct ? 1. As per the provisions of the Constitution, the Council of Ministers is both collectively and individually responsible to the Lok Sabha. 2. A censure motion must state the reason for its adoption. 3. A no-confidence motion must set out the grounds on which it is based. 4. If a no-confidence motion is passed by the Lok Sabha, the Council of Ministers is bound to resign. Select the correct answer using the code given below :
Asked in PPSC CS Prelims 2018 · Topic: The Council of Ministers (Collective Responsibility of the Council of Ministers)
More Indian Polity and Governance questions
- Consider the following statements relevant to the Principles of Ministerial Responsibility:
- Council of Minister is collectively responsible to whom ?
- Given below are two statements, one is labelled as Assertion (A) and other as Reason (R): Assertion (A): The Council of Ministers in India is collectively responsible to both Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha. Reason (R): Members of both Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha are eligible to become Ministers in Union Government. Select the correct answer using the codes given below. Codes
- The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to which of the following ?
- The Council of Ministers has to resign if a no-confidence motion is passed by a majority of members of
- The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible: 1. To the House of the People 2. Under a Constitutional obligation 3. As per Article 75 (3) 4. As per Article 74 (3) Which of the above statements are correct ?
- As per Article 74 (3): Article 74 deals with the Council of Ministers aiding and advising the President. There is no clause (3) in Article 74 related to collective responsibility. The collective responsibility is defined in Article 75(3). 39. As per the Constitution, the Council of Union Ministers is collectively responsible to
- 113) The council of Ministers is responsible to: