The correct answer is C. was caught.

The thief was caught yesterday, so the simple past tense is used. The other options are incorrect because they do not agree with the tense of the sentence.

  • A. is caught is in the present tense, which is not correct because the thief was caught yesterday.
  • B. is being caught is in the present progressive tense, which is not correct because the thief was caught yesterday, not at the moment of speaking.
  • D. has been caught is in the present perfect tense, which is not correct because the thief was caught yesterday, not before yesterday.