The correct answer is: B. in dispute.

The members of the group were at odds over the selection procedure, which means that they were disagreeing or arguing about it. This is supported by the fact that the word "at odds" is often used to describe people who are having a disagreement or argument.

The other options are incorrect because they do not accurately describe the situation. Option A, acting foolishly, is incorrect because there is no evidence that the members of the group were acting foolishly. Option C, unanimous, is incorrect because there is no evidence that the members of the group all agreed on the selection procedure. Option D, behaving childishly, is incorrect because there is no evidence that the members of the group were behaving childishly.

In conclusion, the correct answer is: B. in dispute.