The correct answer is A. All, but she.

The sentence "All, but her, had made an attempt" is grammatically correct. The word "her" is a pronoun that refers to the subject of the sentence, which is "all." The word "had" is the past tense of the verb "to have," and the word "made" is the past tense of the verb "to make." The sentence means that everyone except for her had made an attempt.

The other options are incorrect. Option B, All, but she, is grammatically incorrect because the word "she" is a subject pronoun, and the word "herself" is an object pronoun. Option C, All, but she herself, is grammatically incorrect because the word "herself" is redundant. Option D, No improvement, is incorrect because the sentence is grammatically incorrect.